Back to PenGame

EDDFIRST VS STAR CO

Battle Result

LOTA Result

Clash Summary

EDDFIRST and STAR CO met in Champions League Fixture 3 at Boxpark Croydon. STAR CO won the coin toss and chose to go first. Margs reacts to EDDFIRST's closer with 'that's three' and tells STAR CO he got killed, but the battle is still sent to the QR and website vote and no completed tally is preserved. The result below remains an independent LOTA review rather than an official PenGame decision.

STAR CO's first committed to an extended weight attack. EDDFIRST became Snorlax, too large for a Poké Ball and unable to finish a PenGame foot race. His name supposedly held weight only because his belly had become involved. Jelly Babies, sharing sweets and eating alone developed the food theme. A dog, sheets, meat and ringworm moved into cheeseburgers, fridges and cooking a three-course dinner at night. STAR CO closed with shops, drinks, double-o'clock stages, digging dirt, putting EDDFIRST in the earth and needing a forklift to lift him. The verse is energetic and receives an immediate wheel-up, but most of it stays on one familiar angle.

EDDFIRST's first asked whether STAR CO was nineteen or thirty and blamed a difficult paper round. Paper became newspapers, money and doing free clips while waiting to get paid. A text telling him to kill STAR CO became listening to what Margs said. EDDFIRST called the clash the remains of what VARNTAE had left, then used cash playing hide-and-seek, a lost mind and feet nobody wanted to find. Spice, frequently dyed hair and a facial mark followed. He contrasted STAR CO's lack of stage reaction with the miracle and reactions his own writing could create, before saying throwing STAR CO into the crowd would be the only way anyone caught his wave. A cake-from-his-mother closer returned to weight while keeping the round broader and more opponent-specific.

STAR CO's second said EDDFIRST had once been slim before becoming fat. The central personal alleged that an uncle's kebab shop and sexual abuse had led to free doughnuts. A planned flight to Spain became eating cakes at customs and being removed when the aircraft could not lift. STAR CO questioned how EDDFIRST's legs supported him, then threatened his estate and family. Cheese injections, the fifth dimension, eating a sentence and stealing from Tesco's sweets section closed a short but coherent continuation of the weight theme.

EDDFIRST's second attacked STAR CO for acting like a bad man in a dirty tracksuit. One glove became Michael Jackson and keeping a hand clean for a cousin, leading into an explicit incest allegation based on a previous video. Smoking food versus emptying a fridge and smoking shots versus emptying a clip formed the central parallel. KANDI checking an irrelevant opponent led into STAR CO wearing a fishnet shirt and using Plenty of Fish. Rasta, pasta, disaster, fish, master and pastor created a long name-and-image sequence. EDDFIRST closed by recalling STAR CO bottling an approach to models and by returning to the cousin angle. It is considerably more layered than STAR CO's response.

STAR CO's third opened by warning EDDFIRST not to discuss cousins or press buttons because he had put his hands around J-Walks. John Wick losing his dog became EDDFIRST as a new fluffy friend who took long walks. Cuddling, a bed attachment and John's name became a crude sexual sequence. STAR CO then used riding and a leaning vehicle before Piccolo's Special Beam Cannon, Kamehameha and Goku formed a brief Dragon Ball finish. The round ends quickly and supplies too little material to compete with EDDFIRST's final.

EDDFIRST's third initially tries to play a controversial tune from a live broadcast before the host stops it. He then attacks STAR CO's attempt to market PenGame through an AG TikTok Live, turning marketing art into Stockholm and apologising on Margs's behalf. A mark on STAR CO's cheek, mirror imagery and spelled letters moved into asking why he rapped like he was casting a spell and charging it to hell. EDDFIRST revisited STAR CO saying 'mum's life' before mentioning TRAPPY and accused him of lying. Undertaker, Liverpool, Y2K, Chris Jericho, Venom, episodes, pterodactyl, velodrome, megaphone and echelon drove a long closing rhyme. A top turned red like fake Montclair preceded the final claim that nobody would care if STAR CO died.

LOTA scores EDDFIRST 3-0. EDDFIRST takes the first through the more varied paper-round, money, VARNTAE, reaction and wave writing; wins the second decisively through the Michael Jackson, cousin, food-versus-shots and fishnet construction; and takes the third because STAR CO's brief Dragon Ball response cannot match the contextual TikTok Live, 'mum's life,' wrestling and Montclair closer.

Performance Analysis

EDDFIRST

EDDFIRST wins the LOTA review 3-0. His first answers STAR CO's weight material with paper, money, VARNTAE, stage reaction and crowd-wave angles. His second is the battle's strongest round, connecting the opponent's tracksuit and glove to Michael Jackson before moving through researched cousin and Plenty of Fish material. The final is far longer and more contextual than STAR CO's abbreviated response.

Lyrical Themes: Age and paper rounds; newspapers, free clips and payment; Margs and text messages; VARNTAE; cash, hide-and-seek, lost minds and feet; spice, hair dye and facial marks; miracles, reactions and waves; cake and mothers; bad men, tracksuits, gloves and Michael Jackson; cousins and alleged incest; food, fridges, shots and clips; KANDI; fishnet shirts and Plenty of Fish; rasta, pasta, disaster, fish, masters and pastors; models and bottling; AG, TikTok Live and PenGame marketing; Stockholm; mirrors, cheeks and spelling; casting spells and hell; TRAPPY and 'mum's life'; Undertaker, Liverpool, Y2K, Chris Jericho and Venom; pterodactyls, velodromes, megaphones, Montclair and death.

STAR CO

STAR CO loses the LOTA review 3-0. His first performs well and holds a consistent Snorlax, food and weight theme, but EDDFIRST answers with more variety. The second continues the same angle through a plane and food personal, while the third is especially short. His best technical moment is the Pokémon opener; the Dragon Ball ending arrives cleanly but cannot compensate for the limited final-round volume.

Lyrical Themes: Snorlax and Poké Balls; foot races and running; names carrying weight and bellies; Jelly Babies and sharing sweets; dogs, sheets, meat and ringworm; cheeseburgers, fridges and three-course dinners; shops, drinks, earth, forklifts and lifting; former thinness; kebab shops, doughnuts and alleged abuse; Spain, customs, cakes and aircraft; legs and estates; cheese injections, fifth dimensions, eating sentences and Tesco sweets; cousins and J-Walks; John Wick, dogs, fluffy friends, cuddling and long walks; beds and John's name; vehicles leaning; Piccolo, Special Beam Cannon, Kamehameha and Goku.

Key Technical Highlights

EDDFIRST

Paper-round scheme

Age, newspaper delivery, papers, money and free clipping create a connected opening before EDDFIRST gets paid.

Food versus gunfire parallel

STAR CO smoking food leads to an emptied fridge, while smoking shots leads to EDDFIRST emptying a clip.

Extended closing rhyme

Undertaker, Liverpool, Y2K, Jericho, Venom, episodes, pterodactyl, velodrome, megaphone and echelon sustain the final performance.

STAR CO

Snorlax opener

EDDFIRST's size becomes Snorlax, a Poké Ball, repeated blasts and being the last finisher in a race.

Airport sequence

Spain, customs, cakes, boarding and an aircraft unable to lift build a connected travel and weight passage.

Dragon Ball closer

Piccolo, Special Beam Cannon, Kamehameha and Goku give the brief third a recognisable anime finish.

Indexed Bars & Breakdown

EDDFIRST

Round 1 - Paper round

"Are you nineteen or thirty? I'm mad at your paper round - hand-me-down rapper, never see STAR when paper's round."

A childhood newspaper job explains apparent ageing before paper changes into money and STAR CO's lack of success.

Round 1 - Free clips and paper

"Dedicated to clipping for free, told them, 'When I get paper round.'"

Clipping means making video clips, while paper round means both newspaper work and eventually being paid.

Round 1 - Margs said

"Got a text saying go kill STAR CO, so I had to listen to what Margs said."

A supposed message from the host becomes direct permission to attack the opponent.

Round 1 - VARNTAE left

"I don't care what he's saying in this battle - I'm just killing what VARNTAE left."

EDDFIRST uses STAR CO's previous battle as evidence that the opponent is already damaged.

Round 1 - Hide-and-seek

"Show them all buying, leave your cash playing hide-and-seek - lost your mind, nobody wants to find your feet."

Missing cash becomes a hiding player before lost mind and missing feet extend the search language.

Round 1 - Catching a wave

"If I launch this neek into the crowd, that's the only time they're catching his wave."

Catching an artist's musical wave becomes the crowd physically catching STAR CO.

Round 2 - Bad and glove

"Act like a bad dude, clash in a dirty tracksuit - one glove, Michael Jackson, guess that's what he meant by Bad."

Michael Jackson's single glove and album Bad turn STAR CO's outfit and persona into a music reference.

Round 2 - Cousin glove

"Why did he need the glove? To keep his hand clean for his cousin."

The Michael Jackson glove setup changes into a researched and deliberately offensive family allegation.

Round 2 - Fridge and clip

"You smoke food, I empty the fridge; you smoke shots, I empty the clip."

Smoking food and smoking gunfire create parallel responses through fridge and ammunition clip.

Round 2 - Plenty of Fish

"He was on the net in that fishnet T-shirt - his favourite website's Plenty of Fish."

Net, fishnet and the dating site's name form a connected clothing, fishing and online sequence.

Round 2 - Rasta and pasta

"You're at the bottom of the rasta, your trim looking like pasta - this clash is disaster, nothing but fish to a rasta."

Rasta, pasta, disaster and master sustain the rhyme while attacking hair and identity.

Round 3 - Marketing art

"PenGame mixtape, AG TikTok Live - who let this fool try to market the art like Stockholm?"

Marketing art compresses into market art before Stockholm turns promotion into a city reference.

Round 3 - Mirror and cheek

"Every time he looks in the mirror it's peak - why's that shit on your cheek?"

The facial mark becomes the reason STAR CO's reflection is supposedly difficult to face.

Round 3 - Casting a spell

"Why does he rap like he's casting a spell? Bank test, man has charged you to hell."

Spell-like cadence leads into charging as magical attack and financial payment.

Round 3 - Mum's life

"You said 'mum's life,' weren't mentioning TRAPPY, then dropped his name and swore down, then lied."

EDDFIRST uses a specific prior statement to challenge STAR CO's honesty and credibility.

Round 3 - Montclair finish

"Throw this boy off the top stairs, leave his top red like fake Montclair - if STAR CO died, they would not care."

Top means head and clothing, while a red damaged coat leads into the final name-based death claim.

STAR CO

Round 1 - Snorlax and Poké Ball

"A Snorlax too fat for his Poké Ball - I blast twice and leave him the last one."

The large Pokémon and the ball used to contain it become the central comparison for EDDFIRST's size.

Round 1 - Foot race

"If PenGame hosted a foot race, this guy would finish the last one."

The weight angle becomes a simple prediction about EDDFIRST's speed and endurance.

Round 1 - Name held weight

"Your name don't hold relevance - when it held weight, that's only because your big-man belly got involved."

Holding weight means importance before becoming EDDFIRST's literal body weight.

Round 1 - Jelly Babies

"I bought Jelly Babies to share with the gang - I share sweets, but this jelly man eats all on his own."

The sweet brand and a jelly-like body build a food and selfishness attack.

Round 1 - Dog and ringworm

"You said you're dog in the sheets - if that's true, you're a bully with ringworm, what a nasty disease."

Dog becomes an actual animal before bully means a bully-breed dog and ringworm supplies the infection.

Round 1 - Fridge dinner

"The type of man to raid my fridge at night and cook a three-course dinner."

A late-night snack is exaggerated into a full meal to continue the appetite angle.

Round 1 - Forklift

"I came with a forklift - get fat boy lifted away."

The industrial vehicle is presented as necessary equipment for moving EDDFIRST.

Round 2 - Formerly slim

"EDDFIRST wasn't always fat, he used to be slim - all my life, those ankles used to be shins."

The preserved wording attacks body proportions by saying lower legs have lost their normal shape.

Round 2 - Kebab and doughnuts

"Then his uncle opened a kebab shop - he said nothing because he was getting doughnuts."

The deeply personal allegation is tied back to free food and doughnut-shaped or monetary dough.

Round 2 - Airport cakes

"Packed his bags for Spain, got to customs and ate their cakes - the aircraft couldn't lift, so he got kicked off the plane."

Travel, customs, food and aircraft lift sustain an extended weight-based airport scene.

Round 2 - Legs give way

"How can you stand this? I'm surprised your legs don't give way."

Standing the battle and standing physically merge into another claim that EDDFIRST is too heavy.

Round 2 - Cheese injections

"He's so fat he takes cheese injections."

A medical injection is absurdly replaced with cheese to continue the food caricature.

Round 2 - Eat a sentence

"He's so fat he would eat a sentence - stealing from the Tesco sweetie section."

Eating becomes so exaggerated that language itself is food before the line returns to sweets.

Round 3 - John Wick's dog

"Since John Wick's dog died, he's been alone until he met ED, his new fluffy friend - now they're cuddling and taking long walks."

EDDFIRST is recast as a replacement pet inside the John Wick dog reference.

Round 3 - John's attachment

"I got news: get this bed attached - John's dick, they thought they were so slick."

The preserved wording uses John Wick and John's name for a crude sexual sound flip.

Round 3 - Dragon Ball

"Piccolo, Special Beam Cannon - Kamehameha, I'm Goku, make a man freeze."

Piccolo and Goku's signature Dragon Ball attacks provide the round's anime closer.

Clash Highlights

  • STAR CO's Snorlax and Poké Ball opening earns the battle's first reload.
  • EDDFIRST's paper-round scheme gives his first a compact and coherent opening concept.
  • The food-fridge and shots-clip parallel is the clearest technical moment of the second round.
  • EDDFIRST's Plenty of Fish and long rasta-pasta rhyme receives several reactions.
  • The extended wrestling and velodrome closing sequence prompts the host's emphatic post-battle reaction.
  • Margs jokes that STAR CO changes his name every month during the introduction.
  • STAR CO's opening receives an immediate wheel-up before the microphone levels are adjusted.
  • The no-filming instruction is repeated while one person is told they may film only after the battle.
  • EDDFIRST's second is restarted several times around the Michael Jackson and cousin callback.
  • EDDFIRST attempts to play a controversial live-broadcast tune in his third, but the host immediately stops it to avoid cancellation.
  • The rhythm disappears during EDDFIRST's closing rhyme and the crowd jokes that the DJ wheeled it.
  • Margs reacts with 'that's three' and tells STAR CO he got killed before still sending the battle to the public vote.

Post-Battle Context

Margs reacts to EDDFIRST's final by saying 'that's three' and telling STAR CO he got killed. He then directs the room to the QR code and gives viewers at home 48 hours to vote. Because no completed count or formal winner is preserved, the archive keeps the result explicitly labelled as an independent LOTA decision while noting the host reaction.

Judgement Summary

EDDFIRST wins 3-0 (LOTA Result)

EDDFIRST takes round one through the broader paper-round, payment, VARNTAE, reaction and wave writing. He wins round two decisively with the Michael Jackson glove, cousin, fridge-versus-clip and Plenty of Fish construction. He takes round three because STAR CO's brief John Wick and Dragon Ball material cannot match the detailed TikTok Live, cheek, spell, 'mum's life,' wrestling and Montclair closing round.

Battle Stats

Date31-05-2026
Views39K
LeagueSeason Champions League